Top 100 Keeper League Goalies – May 2019

by Dobber on May 22, 2019

 

Here are the Top 100 goaltenders to own in your keeper leagues – May edition.

 

We're in the midst of the fun months, where I just go team-by-team and tweak without going deep into analysis. The next month will see movement among prospects as I work through the Fantasy Prospects Report (available for pre-sale now and out June 1!). The deep 'audit' type of analysis gets reflected in the August edition after the full work for the annual Fantasy Guide gets done. This month I also tweaked all the UFAs and adjusted a couple of goalies who went deep in the playoffs.

 

As always, goalies within the same tier should be considered equal. At that point you would differentiate based on your team's need – immediate help, or long-term upside, or low-risk (i.e. doesn't get hurt a lot), etc.

 

Some goalies have a higher/lower tier and yet because it is sorted by rating it may not make sense. Goalies are such a hard animal to figure out. A fantasy-useless goalie can become a stud in a matter of a month (ahem, Jordan Binnington). A weaker goalie can be…oh I don't know, sixth… strictly due to getting tons of guaranteed starts on a winning team year after year. If you feel comfortable putting Binnington into the top tier by all means do so – I'm not quite there yet. Thatcher Demko is a Tier 3 goalie on this list because Markstrom had such a great season, is proven and is in his prime. I don't think Demko can wrestle that job away from Markstrom, or at the very least it won't happen this year – so to me he is Tier 3. You may feel different. But his rating reflects this confusion as he is rated higher than some Tier 2 guys. Alex Nedeljkovic had a great AHL campaign and is in an organization with, let's be honest, a question mark future in net. That helps his rating, but can we really put him in the Tier 3 when he is still likely a couple of years away?

 

It's not a perfect science by any stretch, but if you expected a perfect system then  you haven't been playing fantasy hockey for very long!

 

Here are the Top 25, and for the rest of the Top 100 please visit GoaliePost.com – where we now post starters for playoff games.

 

May 20 Goalie Team Rating Apr 20 Tier
1 Andrei Vasilevskiy TBL 113.5 1 0
2 Frederik Andersen TOR 111.5 2 0
3 Braden Holtby WAS 103.9 3 1
4 Connor Hellebuyck WPG 102.2 4 1
5 Tuukka Rask BOS 100.0 5 1
6 Martin Jones SJS 99.1 6 1
7 Sergei Bobrovsky UFA 96.5 7 1
8 Jordan Binnington STL 95.7 11 1
9 Devan Dubnyk MIN 95.4 8 1
10 Carey Price MON 93.8 9 1
11 Marc-Andre Fleury VGK 93.8 10 1
12 Carter Hart PHI 91.6 12 1
13 Jacob Markstrom VAN 91.5 13 2
14 John Gibson ANA 90.7 14 1
15 David Rittich CGY 89.9 15 2
16 Philipp Grubauer COL 89.7 18 2
17 Matt Murray PIT 87.0 16 2
18 Ben Bishop DAL 86.5 17 2
19 Carter Hutton BUF 84.9 19 2
20 Juuse Saros NSH 84.1 20 2
21 Pekka Rinne NSH 83.9 21 2
22 Thatcher Demko VAN 82.2 22 3
23 Petr Mrazek UFA 81.8 25 3
24 Thomas Greiss NYI 81.3 24 2
25 Robin Lehner UFA 80.4 23 2