Why has Desharnais been such a disappointment?

David Desharnais shocked the hockey world on Tuesday night when he registered two assists. Not just because he picked up those points, but because it was the first time in 31 games, including playoffs, that Desharnais had a multi-point game.

Desharnais has fallen from grace recently faster than any player not named Dany Heatley. The undrafted centre is only two seasons removed from a 60-point campaign, but is on pace for just 12 points this year. And those two points on Tuesday night helped immensely in boosting his projected points this year.

What are the reasons for the quick fall of the Montreal Canadiens centre? It's important when looking at Desharnais and what people expected of him that we look at the last three seasons to get a full understanding of what has happened.

Let's start by looking at his most frequent linemates this year.

2013-14 season

Frequency	Strength	Line Combination
11.61%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 32 MOEN,TRAVIS
11.61%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 71 LEBLANC,LOUIS
10.35%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
7.84%	EV	49 BOURNIVAL,MICHAEL – 17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID
7.14%	EV	48 BRIERE,DANIEL – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
4.71%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 48 BRIERE,DANIEL – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID
4.39%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 8 PRUST,BRANDON
4.08%	EV	48 BRIERE,DANIEL – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 8 PRUST,BRANDON
3.84%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 21 GIONTA,BRIAN
3.61%	EV	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 11 GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
2.67%	EV	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 32 MOEN,TRAVIS – 53 WHITE,RYAN
2.51%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID
2.35%	PP	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 48 BRIERE,DANIEL – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID

Desharnais has bounced around the lineup more than a souped-up low rider. He's been paired frequently with fellow underachieving teammate Rene Bourque. However, a name almost absent from this list is Max Pacioretty. DD has only seen Pacioretty as his linemate for 26.7 per cent of his shifts this year.

2012-13 season

Frequency	Strength	Line Combination
39.82%	EV	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 11 GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
12.28%	EV	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
6.9%	PP	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 11 GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
5.58%	EV	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 73 GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
4.55%	EV	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 81 ELLER,LARS
3.44%	PP	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
2.38%	EV	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 8 PRUST,BRANDON
2.26%	EV	17 BOURQUE,RENE – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
1.83%	EV	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX

Last season saw a big change in consistent linemates. Pacioretty shows up on almost every frequent line combination. Overall, 79.7 per cent of Desharnais shifts had MaxPac flanking him.

2011-12 season

Frequency	Strength	Line Combination
50.18%	EV	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
7.65%	PP	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
6.48%	EV	13 CAMMALLERI,MIKE – 72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID
3.08%	EV	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 46 KOSTITSYN,ANDREI – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX
2.13%	PP	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX – 14 PLEKANEC,TOMAS
1.74%	EV	72 COLE,ERIK – 51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID
1.49%	EV	51 DESHARNAIS,DAVID – 67 PACIORETTY,MAX

In his career season in 2011-12, Desharnais played with Pacorietty 74.0 per cent of the time. Knowing how much they've played together goes a long way when looking at Desharnais' point production.

Point production for 2013-14

Total Points for David Desharnais : 3
Str	On Ice Line Combination	Points	%Total Points
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – PACIORETTY,MAX	2	66.67%
EV	BOURQUE,RENE – BRIERE,DANIEL – DESHARNAIS,DAVID	1	33.33%

Point production for 2012-13

Total Points for David Desharnais : 27
Str	On Ice Line Combination	Points	%Total Points
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – PACIORETTY,MAX	13	48.15%
EV	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX	3	11.11%
PP	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX 📢 advertisement:	2	7.41%
PP	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – PACIORETTY,MAX	2	7.41%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX – PRUST,BRANDON	1	3.7%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – GALLAGHER,BRENDAN – PACIORETTY,MAX	1	3.7%
EV	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – ELLER,LARS	1	3.7%
PP	BOURQUE,RENE – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX	1	3.7%
PP	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – ELLER,LARS	1	3.7%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – DUMONT,GABRIEL – PACIORETTY,MAX	1	3.7%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – GIONTA,BRIAN – RYDER,MICHAEL	1	3.7%

Point production for 2011-12

Total Points for David Desharnais : 60
Str	On Ice Line Combination	Points	%Total Points
EV	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX	20	33.33%
PP	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX	14	23.33%
EV	CAMMALLERI,MIKE – COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID	5	8.33%
EV	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX – PLEKANEC,TOMAS	3	5%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – KOSTITSYN,ANDREI – PACIORETTY,MAX	2	3.33%
EV	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID	2	3.33%
PP	CAMMALLERI,MIKE – COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID	1	1.67%
PP	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PLEKANEC,TOMAS	1	1.67%
EV	COLE,ERIK – DARCHE,MATHIEU – DESHARNAIS,DAVID	1	1.67%
EV	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – MOEN,TRAVIS	1	1.67%
PP	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX – PLEKANEC,TOMAS	1	1.67%
EV	CAMMALLERI,MIKE – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – KOSTITSYN,ANDREI	1	1.67%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – LEBLANC,LOUIS – PACIORETTY,MAX	1	1.67%
PP	CAMMALLERI,MIKE – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – KOSTITSYN,ANDREI – PLEKANEC,TOMAS	1	1.67%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX – WHITE,RYAN	1	1.67%
EV	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – GEOFFRION,BLAKE	1	1.67%
PP	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX – PLEKANEC,TOMAS	1	1.67%
EV	BOURQUE,RENE – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – GOMEZ,SCOTT	1	1.67%
EV	DESHARNAIS,DAVID – PACIORETTY,MAX	1	1.67%
PP	COLE,ERIK – DESHARNAIS,DAVID – KOSTITSYN,ANDREI	1	1.67%

Looking at these numbers, there are two main concerns with Desharnais' production:

1) Desharnais depends a lot on Pacoretty. As shown above, 70 of Desharnais' 90 points over the past three seasons have come with MaxPac on the ice. It's great that they have chemistry, but when a coach needs to split the duo up, or when Pacioretty is injured, it means DD is not going to deliver. And that's a big problem when a coach needs to shuffle his lines.

2) As he struggles to score, Desharnais is quickly getting passed by the younger centres who are performing. Lars Eller has had a hot start to the season. Alex Galchenyuk hasn't played a lot at centre but is projected to be the superstar of the future at that position. And with Plekanec already established as a top-six centre, that pushes Desharnais down to the bottom six. That doesn't bode well for his future, and makes it harder for Desharnais to put up points.

This is reflected in Desharnais' ice time: He went from an average of 18:23 TOI two years ago to 16:27 last year to 15:17 this year. His power play ice time has also seen a big dip, going from 3:17 a game in 2011-12 to 2:53 last year to 1:36 this season.

And Desharnais needs to get points, because he doesn't contribute anything else to his hockey team or your fantasy squad: Desharnais doesn't hit (just four in 20 games so far this year), doesn't get you penalty minutes (just six pims) and doesn't block a lot of shots (just 13 this year).

Desharnais is also not great in faceoffs. He's at 50 per cent this year. Last year, he was 50 per cent. The two years before that were 49.5 and 49.7 per cent.

Desharnais isn't a goal scorer — he averages a goal once every six games — despite having some decent shooting percentages. His shooting percentage for the previous three years combined was 15.5 per cent, but he only took 219 shots in 172 games, good for 1.27 shots per game. This year, he's only taken 22 shots in 20 games, for a paltry 1.1 shots per game, and has zero goals to show for it.

So if Desharnais is not getting you points, he's not getting you anything.

There is one final point that gets neglected when you look at Desharnais' career season two years ago. Erik Cole had a big influence on Desharnais. Cole was on the ice for 51 of Desharnais' 60 points in 2011-12. Since Cole was traded to Dallas last year, Desharnais has managed only 21 points in 49 games (not including playoffs).

Maybe the chemistry didn't come from Desharnais and Pacioretty. Maybe the real chemistry was between Desharnais and Cole.

Remember, in that great season, every thing went right for Desharnais: Hot linemates having a career year; an injury to Brian Gionta and Scott Gomez having a horrific season which opened up spots in the top six; and the Canadiens being really bad in the standings and losing a lot of games (meaning the top offensive line was on the ice late in games as opposed to defensive players used to protect a lead). All of these factors led to more TOI, PP time and offensive opportunities for Desharnais.

Desharnais' two-point effort on Tuesday night was an anomaly for the Montreal forward, and he should be avoided in all types of leagues except for the very deepest of fantasy leagues.

Previously in Frozen Pool Forensics:

Nail Yakupov

Brad Marchand