Capped: Top 10 Bounce Back Candidates
Eric Daoust
2014-09-25
Looking at what 10 bounce back candidates might do for you in salary cap leagues.
Back on August 5th, Tom Collins covered his top 10 bounce-back candidates for the 2014-15 campaign. After a season that fails to live up to expectations, many fantasy managers are down on those players and often lose perspective. The truth is that players go through many ups and downs over the course of their careers. Even though nothing is certain, it is very reasonable to expect a proven asset to bounce back following a down year and many of these players will be undervalued come draft time.
However, in cap leagues it is a much different game when it comes to gambling on bounce-back years. Not only is the player actually bouncing back a risk in itself, but the player's cap hit – generally on the high end for proven guys – presents more of a problem. Depending on the situation, a failed bounce-back can prove to be disastrous. Sometimes, the risk is not worth the reward and you are better off going with safer, more reasonable contracts.
Today we will analyze each of the 10 players Collins covered in a cap league context.
Dion Phaneuf (7,000,000)
Phaneuf had a down year offensively but still scored extremely well on the multi-category front. In leagues that take advantage of his all-around stats he remains a star and should be owned regardless of a bounce-back. However, in points-only formats you may want to gamble on a cheaper alternative and invest the leftover money elsewhere as Phaneuf is not consistent enough to justify the risk.
Pascal Dupuis (3,750,000)
Dustin Brown (5,875,000)
In points-only leagues, forget about it. Brown still has 50-point upside but at this point is far too risky with that huge contract. However, if your league counts hits and shots there is a chance that he could still be a decent guy to own if you can fit his salary in your payroll. This determination is very league-specific though and requires more research for your setting. Proceed with caution.
Bobby Ryan (5,100,000)
In one-year leagues Ryan should be owned in all formats. His disappointing 48 points from last year is the absolute worst you can expect from him and he has the upside to produce some very impressive numbers. On the flip side, his keeper-league value could take a major hit soon because he is in the final year of his current contract. If he has a big year and cashes in on the free agent market, his new cost could get out of hand. If he gets off to a strong start, you may want to look into trading him for a similar player that is not due for a new deal.
Ondrej Pavelec (3,900,000)
The only questionable entry in the list as an actual bounce-back candidate is Pavelec, who has only been above the .906 mark once in his career. Not much of a bounce-back if he has been borderline awful the majority of the time. The silver lining is that his cap hit ranks 20th among goaltenders so he is not a complete albatross. Still, the production has simply not been there at any point. You may want to gamble on a cheaper guy with a better history or just pay up and grab one of the upper-tier starters.
Sergei Gonchar (5,000,000)
Despite turning into a fantasy liability last year, there is a bit of hope with Gonchar. He had a strong year back in 2012-13 and has been an excellent point-producer over the years. Unfortunately, at $5 million there is simply too much risk even on an improving Stars team. There are simply too many alternatives out there that cost less to own and will probably out-produce the veteran blueliner anyway.
Alexander Edler (5,000,000)
From a points-only perspective, Edler should be considered high-risk due to his large cap hit. He provides better value than Gonchar considering he is still less than 30 years old and has many productive years left. His value is maximized in multi-category though where his combination of points, hits, blocks, PPP and shots on goal still make him a decent buy as long as he can improve offensively and regulate his plus-minus.
Braden Holtby (1,850,000)
Holtby is another goalie that has some uncertainties heading into this season but unlike Pavelec is dirt cheap and has a great statistical history at the NHL level. A bounce-back campaign could put him at the top of the heap in terms of bang for the buck. With most starters costing more than $4 million, you should move Holtby up several spots in your draft ranking.