The Contrarian – Top-50 Update

Thomas Drance

2014-12-28

CrosbyOvechkin

The Contrarian provides a top-50 update and wishes you a happy holidays!

Earlier in the summer I posted a column about a free contest where I asked you to predict the Top 50 players based on total points. The reason behind the contest was to see if the consensus picks were better or worse than the individual predictions of the participants.

 

The actual entries and standings can be found in the forum, click here to see, however, this article is going to focus on the consensus and other interesting information.

 

There are 18 participants, and as of Tuesday Dec 23rd, the best of which has a Missed Opportunity score of 260 points and the worst 330. The consensus score would be 296 and that would rank 15th. That means only four participants are doing worse than the consensus.

 

If someone were to just use last year's Top 50 rankings that would earn them a Missed Opportunity score of 345, placing them dead last among the competitors. At least for now it shows that using the previous year's results isn't a solid plan.

Looks pretty good but let us dig further.

 

There are 15 players (21 because of a tie at the 50th spot, but only one of those players could rank as the 50th best) which none of our participants selected. It didn't matter where the player was predicted to be, thirty percent of the Top 50, was not selected by any of our participants. Some of these guys rank very high too.

 

Vladimir Tarasenko (sixth), Mark Giordano (12th), Jiri Hudler (15th), Filip Forsberg (16th), Nick Foligno (17th), Nikita Kucherov (18th), Kevin Shattenkirk (32nd), Brock Nelson (34th), Jaden Schwartz (39th), Ryan Callahan (40th), Brent Burns (41st), Johnny Gaudreau (42nd), Kris Versteeg (47th) and Jori Lehtera (48th) all clearly make the Top 50 with 25 points or more. The players not selected that are tied with Pavel Datsyuk for 50th are Alex Galchenyuk, Tyler Toffoli, Sami Vatanen, Derek Brassard, TJ Brodie, Valtteri Filppula and John Carlson. Chances are that if you have any of these players on your points only league rosters you got them at a good price and are doing well. That doesn't help though in predicting that these guys were going to this well.

 

Another eight players were selected by less than half the participants, Tyler Johnson (13th), Rick Nash (14th), Mike Ribiero (29th) and Ryan Kesler (36th) just to name a few.

The flipside to this are those players that were selected by everyone (or mostly everyone) and are not in the Top 50.

 

Those players include, David Krejci, Patrick Sharp, Nathan MacKinnon, Jordan Eberle, Chris Kunitz, Matt Duchesne, Taylor Hall, Corey Perry, Anze Kopitar, Martin St. Louis, Blake Wheeler, Erik Karlsson, Thomas Vanek, and Eric Staal.

 

Sure some of those players have had injuries but not all of them. Within the competitors the fact that most of them had these players kind of washes out. That doesn't mean that they were good predictions though. The consensus would be earning worse score.

Ranks # Perfect Average
1 to 10 36 2.00
11 to 20 18 1.00
21 to 30 20 1.11
31 to 40 20 1.11
41 to 50 6 0.33

 

One of the participants was able to get nine perfect predictions and a few others got eight. The consensus and the rankings based on the previous year each only got four correct predictions.

 

To better see where the Missed Opportunities really lie you need to see the results in the table below: One of the participants was able to get nine perfect predictions and a few others got eight. The consensus and the rankings based on the previous year each only got four correct predictions.

 

To better see where the Missed Opportunities really lie you need to see the results in the table below:

 

Ranks 1 to 10 11 to 20 21 to 30 31 to 40 41 to 50
Total Missed Opportunity 1070 1142 1014 992 1012
Avg. Missed Opportunity 59.44 63.44 56.33 55.11 56.22

 

Basically the misses are consistently throughout the Top 50 ranks and there seems to be no easy predictions, not even within the Top 10.

 

Only two more things that I want to show, the first of which is the worse player missed opportunities.

 

There is Alexander Semin and Taylor Hall with a missed opportunity score of 21 each. Semin was predicted in the later ranks but hasn't produced while Hall was predicted in the higher ranks and even though he has many more points than Semin he hasn't justified his high rank by one owner. For another unfortunate owner, Jakub Voracek was predicted 50th instead of first and thus created a missed opportunity score of 20. Others negative predictions include Taylor Hall, Nathan MacKinnon and David Krejci with score values between 19 and 18. 

 

The consensus and last year's ranks also had Krejci ranked high and it produced a score of 19 for them.

 

Lastly, I took the liberty to check what Dobber's Guide had ranked the players and the August edition would have scored 271 (the October edition, 268) which would place it in second place for the moment. Pretty good if you ask me.

 

So while you are digesting you festive meals, you might take some time to ponder these results. If you didn't participate in the contest this summer, maybe you'll do so next year and if you want a tip I got from Santa… it doesn't hurt to get Dobber's Guide.

 

Happy Holidays!! 

Leave A Comment

UPCOMING GAMES

Mar 29 - 13:03 PHI vs BUF
Mar 29 - 14:03 T.B vs NYI
Mar 29 - 16:03 COL vs STL
Mar 29 - 18:03 MIN vs N.J
Mar 29 - 18:03 NSH vs VGK
Mar 29 - 19:03 L.A vs TOR
Mar 29 - 19:03 OTT vs CBJ
Mar 29 - 20:03 DET vs BOS
Mar 29 - 22:03 EDM vs CGY
Mar 29 - 22:03 S.J vs NYR
Mar 29 - 22:03 SEA vs DAL

Starting Goalies

Top Skater Views

  Players Team
DYLAN COZENS OTT
DYLAN HOLLOWAY STL
LANE HUTSON MTL
PIUS SUTER VAN
MATVEI MICHKOV PHI

Top Goalie Profile Views

  Players Team
FREDERIK ANDERSEN CAR
KEVIN LANKINEN VAN
IGOR SHESTERKIN NYR
LUKAS DOSTAL ANA
ADIN HILL VGK

LINE COMBOS

  Frequency MIN Players
20.7 GUSTAV NYQUIST RYAN HARTMAN MARCUS FOLIGNO
20.2 MATS ZUCCARELLO MARCUS JOHANSSON FREDERICK GAUDREAU
18.0 MARCO ROSSI VINNIE HINOSTROZA MATT BOLDY

DobberHockey Podcasts

Fantasy Hockey Life: Scouts Tout

Scout’s Tout returns with breakdowns of Will Zellers, Collin Graf, Artyom Levshunov, Max Plante, Roman Kantserov, Zayne Parekh, and Carter Yakemchuk. Thanks to the FHL Scouts who contributed to this episode: Tony, Jeremy, Grant, Craig, and Patrick. Polls from NHL Rank King Mason Black. Have a listen! Our show is part of the Dobber Podcast […]

Keeping Karlsson: Kuzmenko On First

On this edition of the Keeping Karlsson Fantasy Hockey Podcast mega-show, Elan and Brian grieve their KKUPFL seasons in real time while helping you continue on towards your path to league championships, by raising the big shows and the no-shows heading into your fantasy hockey playoffs.

Keeping Karlsson Short Shifts – Three Cs Becoming Three Os

Elan and Shams are here to update you on the recent injury news headlined by Draisaitl and the potential light at the end of the tunnel for Shea Theodore’s return. They close out the show discussing hot Blues, cold Defencemen and Shams trying to convince Elan about some potential streaky players to add.

Keeping Karlsson: Hellllooooooo, Nyman

On this edition of the Keeping Karlsson Fantasy Hockey Podcast mega-show, Elan and Brian are highlighting the teams with the best and worst fantasy playoff schedules, and the players that are worth adding, holding or dropping as you get to the most crucial moments of your fantasy season.

FIND US ON FACEBOOK