Dobber's offseason fantasy hockey grades – San Jose


For the last 12 years over at The Hockey News, I have reviewed each team from a fantasy-hockey standpoint and graded them. Now that I am no longer with THN, my 13th annual review will appear here on DobberHockey. This is not a review of the likely performance on the ice or in the standings, but in the realm of fantasy hockey.



GoneJohn Scott, Matt Irwin, Antti Niemi, Adam Burish, Scott Hannan, Todd McLellan (coach)


IncomingJoel Ward, Paul Martin, Martin Jones, Joonas Donskoi, Peter DeBoer (coach)


Impact of changes – The Sharks moved towards some tight-checking players who show up well in fancy stats (Martin) and are good in the clutch (Ward). Also hiring a tight-checking coach strongly indicates that this could be more of a defensive squad. The likes of Joe Pavelski could see his offense decline in the year ahead.

In net, the Sharks didn't get anywhere with Niemi. And Stalock had a bad year, so they couldn't trust him with enough certainty. So they acquired Jones, who is probably equal to Stalock in terms of proven ability and upside. In a tighter-checking system, these two goalies will flourish – but with the starts split, fantasy owners will still be downgrading them.


Ready for full-time – Donskoi is a former Florida draft pick whom the Panthers allowed to walk – and then he decided that was the time to break out. In the Finnish League the 23-year-old had 49 points in 58 games last season to lead Karpat in scoring (and fifth in the league). He also had eight points in eight games for Team Finland at the Worlds, which certainly got the Sharks' attention as they signed him right after. The upside here is Jori Lehtera. The downside is Janne Pesonen.

Matt Tennyson is a two-way defender who got into 27 games for San Jose last season and at 25 years of age, is ready to make the jump. I'd expect his progress and offensive development to mimic that of Justin Braun.

Nikolay Goldobin is the next big talent for San Jose. Drafted 27th overall last summer, he boasts tremendous upside thanks to his creativity and goal-scoring ability. He is a little small and needs to add strength, which is why I don't think he plays more than a handful of games for the Sharks next season. He'll be ready a year from now, though.


Fantasy Outlook – The Sharks have fallen upon hard times of late, and their solution to fix it appears to be via defensive hockey. That's the bane of fantasy hockey's existence. While their prospect talent pool is rather shallow, they continue to roll in one or two real solid rookies each season. And now they have Goldobin, Kevin Labanc, Rourke Chartier and Timo Meier on the way.


Fantasy Grade: C+ (last year was B-)




Pick up the 10th annual DobberHockey Fantasy Hockey Guide here


Get the Fantasy Guide, the Prospects Report, the Midseason Guide, the Playoff Draft List all for just $10 here!


Fantasy Grades: Anaheim Ducks

Fantasy Grades: Arizona Coyotes

Fantasy Grades: Boston Bruins

Fantasy Grades: Buffalo Sabres

Fantasy Grades: Calgary Flames

Fantasy Grades: Carolina Hurricanes

Fantasy Grades: Chicago Blackhawks

Fantasy Grades: Colorado Avalanche

Fantasy Grades: Columbus Blue Jackets

Fantasy Grades: Dallas Stars

Fantasy Grades: Detroit Red Wings

Fantasy Grades: Edmonton Oilers

Fantasy Grades: Florida Panthers

Fantasy Grades: Los Angeles Kings

Fantasy Grades: Minnesota Wild

Fantasy Grades: Montreal Canadiens

Fantasy Grades: Nashville Predators

Fantasy Grades: New York Islanders

Fantasy Grades: New Jersey Devils

Fantasy Grades: New York Rangers

Fantasy Grades: Ottawa Senators

Fantasy Grades: Philadelphia Flyers

Fantasy Grades: Pittsburgh Penguins