The Journey: Surprising NHL Rookies Making Noise
Victor Nuno
2026-02-21
Welcome back to The Journey, where we track how prospect development curves translate into real fantasy relevance. Every season produces a handful of rookies who outperform expectations, not because they were overlooked entirely, but because their timelines accelerated faster than anticipated. Sometimes it's a role opening sooner than planned, sometimes it's skill translating more cleanly than projected, and sometimes it's simply readiness meeting opportunity.
This check-in focuses on rookies who have quietly forced their way into the NHL conversation through strong early returns, role clarity, or underlying indicators that suggest staying power. Not all of these players will become fantasy staples, but each has done enough to warrant closer attention.
Forwards
Oliver Kapanen – C, Montreal Canadiens
As a prospect, Kapanen was viewed more as a well-rounded, two-way player than a pure scorer. Through his first 50 NHL games, however, he has begun to show flashes of high-end offensive upside. According to Evolving Hockey, he currently sits around the 80th percentile in even strength offense, with expected offensive metrics that significantly outpace his actual production.

What makes that especially encouraging is that his results have come despite limited deployment. He has seen minimal power play opportunities, 10th among forwards, and relatively modest even strength usage, ranking roughly seventh among forwards. If his role expands and those underlying numbers begin to convert into tangible scoring, there may be more offensive growth still to come.
Linus Karlsson – C, Vancouver Canucks
Karlsson's physical maturity and direct offensive approach have translated better than many expected at the NHL level. He plays a straight-line game, gets inside positioning, and wins space along the boards, allowing him to generate chances from high value areas rather than relying on perimeter touches. A great visualization of his impact comes from Micah Blake McCurdy's HockeyViz work. The charts show a modest but positive offensive influence, particularly at five on five, while the defensive side remains more muted. The key takeaway is his +1.5 Synthetic Goals, a metric designed to combine overall impact, including shots for and against, penalties, scoring contributions, and usage across all strengths.

Synthetic Goals help capture the full picture of a player who may not drive play independently but still moves the needle in meaningful ways. Karlsson has gained a little over thirty seconds of ice time compared to last season, though most of that increase has come on the power play rather than at even strength. If his deployment shifts toward a more offensive five on five role, there may be additional scoring upside waiting to emerge. He is unlikely to be a primary driver, but his finishing ability and willingness to attack the interior give him sneaky value in deeper fantasy formats, especially if Vancouver continues to reward his efficiency with stronger opportunities.
Justin Sourdif – C, Washington Capitals
Sourdif's skill has never really been in question, but his transition to the NHL has happened faster than many expected. He processes the game quickly, supports play well through the middle of the ice, and shows enough creativity in tight areas to keep plays alive even in limited minutes. What stands out most is his pace of decision making, he does not hold onto the puck unnecessarily and consistently positions himself as an outlet, which has helped him earn trust despite modest deployment. The underlying numbers support the eye test as well, according to Evolving Hockey he is already sitting around the 80th percentile among all forwards, with both his even strength offense and defense grading near the 63rd percentile.

If his role expands beyond more sheltered usage, there is reason to believe the offense could follow. Sourdif's instincts around the puck suggest he can provide secondary scoring while maintaining responsible defensive play, which is often how depth forwards carve out long term value. He may not project as a high-volume scorer, but the combination of strong underlying impacts, physical engagement, and reliable two way play hints at a forward who could grow into a meaningful depth option, especially if given more consistent even strength opportunity and situational offensive looks.
Ben Kindel – C, Pittsburgh Penguins
Kindel's early returns suggest a player whose intelligence and timing are driving his success more than raw tools. He consistently finds soft spots in coverage, supports play effectively, and makes quick, efficient decisions with the puck that help stabilize shifts even when he is not the focal point of the offense. Many viewed his selection at 11th overall in 2025 as a bit of a reach at the time, but his performance this season has quickly challenged that narrative. While some players from that draft class who have yet to debut may ultimately carry higher offensive ceilings, what Kindel has already accomplished at the NHL level is undeniably impressive.

According to his HockeyStats.com player card, Kindel is already contributing strongly at both even strength offense and defense, leading to an impressive 81% wins above replacement (WAR) mark. The projection currently leans toward a long term third line profile, which may ultimately be where he settles, but the underlying impacts suggest there is still meaningful room for growth. If his confidence with the puck continues to develop and his offensive role expands, Kindel could push beyond a pure support role and become a quietly valuable contributor in both real life and deeper fantasy formats.
Danila Yurov – C, Minnesota Wild
Yurov entered the NHL looking far more pro ready than many anticipated, carrying over the strength, puck protection, and offensive awareness that made him a standout with Metallurg Magnitogorsk in the KHL. Yurov led Metallurg in scoring in 2023-24 despite receiving only the seventh most ice time. The early NHL results have been quieter offensively, but he has held his own and shown flashes that hint at more scoring upside as his role continues to grow. His ice time has steadily increased, and Minnesota's lack of center depth gives him a real opportunity to carve out a larger role, especially if he can develop chemistry with countryman Kirill Kaprizov. That connection has not fully materialized yet, but the looks are there, and if he earns consistent top six usage his fantasy ceiling could rise quickly, though any external addition at center would likely cap that upside.
Arseny Gritsyuk – LW, New Jersey Devils
Gritsyuk's offensive confidence has translated well from his strong KHL and international play into his first NHL season, where his creativity, edge work, and willingness to attack defenders one on one make him a constant threat with the puck. While consistency and defensive trust remain areas to monitor, his early underlying results have been encouraging, with both offensive and defensive impacts grading above the 70th percentile. He currently ranks seventh among Devils forwards in total ice time, has received occasional top six looks, and is seeing regular second unit power play usage, suggesting his role could continue to grow. If that progression holds and his opportunity expands, it may be an ideal time to invest before the scoring fully catches up to the underlying performance.
Noah Ostlund – C, Buffalo Sabres
Ostlund's transition has been defined by poise and intelligence, with a game built around strong reads, puck support, and the ability to extend offensive-zone possession rather than driving highlight reel scoring chances. The long-term vision has always been for him to center a middle or bottom six line, and after a solid AHL season, he has begun to show that he can handle that responsibility at the NHL level. Defensively, he has already looked excellent, profiling as a potential shutdown center who can stabilize matchups and earn trust in difficult minutes, while his offensive impact has remained more average so far. If his confidence with the puck grows and his usage expands slightly, there is still room for him to develop into a useful fantasy depth piece over time.
Justin Hryckowian – LW, Dallas Stars
Hryckowian has been one of the more unexpected early success stories, with his pace and work rate translating better than many anticipated at the NHL level. Expectations were modest at first, but a stellar final NCAA season at Northwestern followed by a 60-point AHL campaign in 67 games earned him his opportunity, and he has held his own despite limited ice time on a deep Dallas roster. He brings energy, pushes play north, and has chipped in offensively without needing heavy deployment, even earning occasional looks alongside Mikko Rantanen and Wyatt Johnston. His fantasy value may remain format dependent for now, but if his role continues to grow, he could develop into a quietly useful depth contributor.
Defensemen
Tom Willander – Vancouver Canucks
Willander entered the league with the reputation of a defense-first blueliner, but his first 51 NHL games have complicated that narrative. His skating and poise have helped him transition the puck efficiently, and with Quinn Hughes now in Minnesota, he has quietly earned the third most power play time on ice among Vancouver defenders, trailing only Zeev Buium and Filip Hronek, while also benefiting from 56% offensive zone starts. The offensive flashes have been encouraging, with underlying impacts suggesting real value when play is tilted toward the attacking end.

However, the defensive results have lagged far behind expectations, as his metrics sit near the bottom of the league, including a second percentile defensive rating per Evolving Hockey. For fantasy managers, the profile may be shifting from safe shutdown option to offense-leaning contributor. If Willander can stabilize his defensive play even modestly, his usage and early offensive indicators suggest a path toward becoming a more complete, fantasy-relevant defenseman.
Artyom Levshunov – Chicago Blackhawks
Levshunov's season has been a mix of clear promise and expected growing pains, reinforcing both the upside and volatility that shaped his projection entering the year. The physical tools still stand out, his skating lets him close space quickly, he activates confidently into the rush, and his shot continues to generate offensive pressure from the blue line. Chicago has shown significant trust in his development, as he ranks second among Blackhawks defenders in total time on ice and leads the group in power play usage. That deployment has translated into tangible fantasy relevance already, with Levshunov tracking toward a 33-point pace while contributing solid blocks, shots, and hits, making him especially useful in BASH or multi-category formats.

The concern remains on the defensive side, where the results have been difficult to ignore. HockeyViz data shows Chicago surrendering roughly 15% more chances with him on the ice, including a heavy concentration of danger directly in front of the net, and Evolving Hockey rates him with the team's worst expected goals against and expected goals differential. For fantasy managers, the profile remains high variance but intriguing. If his defensive reads and structure begin to stabilize, the pathway toward a power play driven, top pair fantasy defenseman is still very real, but until that growth happens, he carries meaningful risk despite the strong usage and category coverage.
Goalies
Brandon Bussi – Carolina Hurricanes
After a strong NCAA career at Western Michigan and several impressive seasons with the Providence Bruins in the AHL, Bussi has burst onto the NHL scene this year and now sits third in the league in wins. While the Hurricanes provide a strong defensive environment, not every goalie thrives in that system, and Frederik Andersen's uneven results highlight that Bussi's success still requires execution and confidence. You can see from his Evolving-Hockey goalie chart that Bussi has massively outperformed his expected numbers, reinforcing that this isn't purely a byproduct of team structure.

Bussi's ability to outperform expected goals suggests legitimate long-term value rather than a simple hot streak, though some regression should be expected if the gap between results and underlying metrics remains this wide. His calm positioning and rebound control allow him to maximize the strong structure in front of him, and if his usage continues to grow, he could evolve into a high-end tandem starter with stretches of clear number one fantasy value, particularly in formats that reward wins.
Jesper Wallstedt – Minnesota Wild
Wallstedt's long-term fantasy profile has always been built on technical precision and composure, and this season has helped reestablish that trajectory after a difficult 2024–25 AHL campaign. Minnesota's decision not to bring in a veteran to block his path signaled continued organizational belief, and he has rewarded that confidence with steady play. Among goaltenders with comparable workload, he currently ranks 23rd in goals saved above expected, reflecting a level of stability that aligns well with his projection as a reliable volume starter rather than a volatile, highlight-driven option.

Underlying data adds more context to the performance. Evolving Hockey's charts suggest he has benefited from strong even-strength protection, and he has capitalized by delivering efficient, low-dramatic results behind a structured defensive environment. On the penalty kill, however, he has faced more difficult conditions and still managed to post positive outcomes, reinforcing the idea that his calm positioning and technical foundation can hold up under pressure. For fantasy managers, the outlook is encouraging, a high-floor goaltender whose value comes from consistency, with room to grow if Minnesota continues to solidify in front of him.
Final Thoughts
The biggest takeaway from this group is how quickly timelines can shift when opportunity meets readiness. Players like Kapanen, Sourdif, and Gritsyuk are showing that strong underlying impacts and smart deployment can quietly push a rookie into fantasy relevance even without headline production, while others such as Willander, Levshunov, and Bussi highlight how growth often comes with volatility and evolving roles. For fantasy managers, the edge comes from watching usage and underlying metrics as closely as raw scoring totals, many of these players are only a small change in deployment away from a meaningful jump in value, and identifying those moments early is often what separates short-term hype from long-term gains.
Thanks for reading! See you next week. For more fantasy hockey analysis, or if there's a prospect, topic, or theme you'd like me to cover, follow and message me on X: https://x.com/VictorNuno12