Capped: Toews, Boldy, and Batherson Providing Cap League Bargains
Andrew Santillo
2026-11-19
Hey all, welcome back! Last week, we looked at several players who got off to hot starts before cooling down. One of those names was Vasily Podkolzin. After a two-goal performance against Florida on Tuesday night, he’s back to producing offensively. Some of that is tied to Ryan Nugent-Hopkins missing time, but regardless of the reason, fantasy managers will gladly take the production.
This week, most of us have probably started our holiday shopping. As part of a large Italian family, I’m always hunting for a bargain. The same concept applies to fantasy hockey, where several players around the league are providing excellent value for salary-cap and dynasty managers.
Devon Toews (32, D) – Colorado Avalanche ($7.25M AAV)
I’ve talked before about how many high-AAV defensemen end up clogging waiver wires in dynasty and salary-cap formats. That’s why finding reliable production in the $4M-$7M range can be such a difference-maker.
I’ve been fortunate enough to roster Toews this season, and while my team has been taking its lumps on a weekly basis, Toews has been one of the few bright spots, and his stock is definitely up right now. With Cale Makar sidelined, Toews has taken on top-pairing minutes and first power-play responsibilities. He currently sits tied for 10th among NHL defensemen in scoring and has continued to produce despite Colorado dealing with injuries to both Makar and Nathan MacKinnon.
At 32 years old, there is some age-related risk over the next few seasons. For now, though, you’re getting strong offensive production from a position that can be difficult to fill. The Avalanche have had a lighter schedule over the past couple of weeks, which could ultimately help the lineup get healthier. With 12 points in his last 11 games, Toews has been tremendous for fantasy managers looking for value on the blue line.
Matt Boldy (25, LW/RW) – Minnesota Wild ($7M AAV)
I was this close (holding my thumb and index finger together) to drafting Matt Boldy in one of my ESPN leagues. Unfortunately, I passed on him. Fortunately for him, I got to face him during the last matchup period. It was fun. We’re all having fun.
The Wild have Boldy under contract through his age-29 season, and if his game continues to develop, I could easily be writing about him as one of the league’s biggest bargains even at a higher cap hit a few years from now.
Through 23 games, Boldy has posted 12 goals and 12 assists, putting him on pace for roughly 40 goals and 90 points. That’s elite production at a $7-million cap hit. Position eligibility can also be a huge advantage in dynasty formats, and Boldy’s LW/RW flexibility only adds to his value. With the salary cap continuing to rise in both fantasy and the NHL, Boldy’s contract could look like an absolute steal for managers building around a strong forward core.
Drake Batherson (28, LW/RW) – Ottawa Senators ($5M AAV)
Drake Batherson is an interesting case. At $5-million this season, he’s unquestionably a bargain. Next year, however, his cap hit jumps significantly to $10.75 million, making the calculation much different.
Even dating back to last season, Batherson has consistently produced. He finished with 71 points a year ago, and that total feels very attainable again this season considering he’s already managed 20 points in 22 games this season.
His current 22% shooting percentage suggests some regression is likely coming, but I believe his even-strength play is strong enough to keep him productive throughout the season. From a fantasy perspective, I’d love to see him spend more time on the top line alongside Tim Stützle, but he’s still producing at an impressive rate while skating on Ottawa’s second unit.
If Batherson continues producing at a 70- to 80-point pace, I’m perfectly comfortable with his value. If that production slips into the 50-point range after next year’s salary increase, I would be concerned. For now, though, he’s one of the better bargains you’ll find in salary-cap leagues.
For continued fantasy news and notes, follow me on Twitter @ndySanz.