The Advantage of Band-Aid Boys (and Windex Wonders)

Dobber Sports

2013-04-12

 

AlexSteen

Editors note: Many thanks to Cyril (also known as seadawg on the forums) for updating the Windex Wonders (streaky players) and Band-Aid Boys (injury-prone players) lists. Read on for more of his thoughts on both kinds of players.

 

We often hear people complaining about streaky players (i.e., Windex Wonders) and injury-prone players (i.e., Band-Aid Boys), but this article is going to talk about the value those type of players can bring to your fantasy squad, in some situations.

 

For starters, I want to point out that not all Windex Wonders or Band-Aid Boys are created equal. I mean, in no league whatsoever can you argue on the merit of having Rick Dipietro on your team. Also, I'm not considering the superstars of the league (Crosby, Stamkos, Malkin, Sedins), no matter what category they belong to. For the most part, the elite superstars of the NHL are going to be owned in any league, no matter the format.

I'm talking about players like Thomas Vanek, Alexi Semin, Marian Gaborik, Jason Spezza, and Henrik Zetterberg. These players are both injury-prone and streaky. They have tantalizing skills and tease us with their potential, but they can't be relied upon to remain healthy long-term, nor put up consistent numbers. Because of this, many avoid them altogether in their fantasy drafts (and rightly so) and would rather go with players that are less injury-prone and more consistent. I'm talking about players like Eric Staal, Joe Thornton, Mike Ribeiro, David Krejci, and Patrik Elias. I certainly agree that in most leagues, you want consistent, healthy players on your roster.

However, there are some leagues in which you may actually want the high-risk/high-reward player. If you are able to set your roster on a daily or even weekly basis, you can benefit from having high-risk players. For example, one of my leagues has been running with the same members for almost 20 years and I have learned something from observing which teams are successful. This league is a head-to-head (H2H) league with weekly starts. It is a 12-team league with 18 player rosters. Each Sunday, we set our rosters with any 3 forwards, 2 dmen, and 1 goalie to go up against our opponent for the week. Having someone like Eric Staal (who I have on my team this year) and his consistent, reliable production, is nice. In any given wee