The Contrarian: A 30 Year Old Geek

Dobber Sports


USATSI 7565602 154511096 lowres

A closer look at last weekend’s “Geek of the Week”: Scottie Upshall


This week Terry Campkin wrote about Scottie Upshall and his successful season so far. It made me think of last week's buy low and sell high targets and how Upshall should be a sell now player.


I like how Terry methodically goes through his research and analysis but I have some of my own.


Terry asks two things, "Why is this happening? And – is this sustainable?" I have no objections to using frozen pool to validate the player's output but basing it on the past three games is a bit of an over reach especially since Upshall has not produced like this in the past. That being said, when you are buying low you do take chances. So the answer to why is that he has been given more opportunity to shine.


In my efforts to discover if this opportunity can last or will it disappear I found several notes about Scottie.


In The Hockey News Ultimate Pool Guide 2007-08 the individual player caption reads, "Upshall did something with the Flyers he failed to do with Nashville – make an impression. He's set up this season on a scoring line, so expect decent numbers". He went on to get 30 points in 61 games.


The Hockey News Fantasy Pool Guide 2008-09 indicated, "Upshall has played parts of five NHL seasons and last year was his first full one. Injuries are a problem and rising above the third line is a bigger problem". That does not sound like he made the impression that was expected from the previous season. From the Score Sports Forecaster 2008-09 NHL Preview & Fantasy Guide, "Upshall brings lots of speed and energy to the table but, as the No. 6 overall pick in 2002, where is the consistent offense? In 2007-08, he had an excellent opportunity to showcase his skills but remains outside the Flyer's top six forwards." Oh-oh. He had lost opportunities before. This could mean that he will likely lose out on opportunities again.


In the THN Ultimate Fantasy Pool Guide 2009-10, the comment was "Energy player gets third-line scoring numbers." For the 2010-11 guide it said, "Was having a great offensive season before injury. Even so, that was out of character" and the 2011-12 guide had, "Third-liner mostly brings potatoes to the party. Don't expect desert."


The next two THN guides do not even have a blurb about him. His projected values were 24 and 26 points for the season. He registered five points in each of those seasons.


Terry assumes that he has not been given an opportunity like this before when he wrote, "I open up my guide from this season and see that Upshall has an up