Ramblings: Zaitsev, Sid, Henrik, Rinne, Shipachyov and more (May 03)
Dobber
2017-05-03
Ramblings: Zaitsev, Sid, Henrik, Rinne, Shipachyov and more (May 03)
***
As you know (judging by the million comments in the Ramblings yesterday – touchy subject!), Sidney Crosby is out for Game 4 with a concussion. Given it’s Crosby and given that even a mild concussion costs at least two games, my guess is that Crosby is out for Games 5 and 6 as well. I can only hope that it won’t be something more serious. As many times as we’ve seen the replay, we can argue about intent or suspension all day long. But what we can probably agree on is that the jab to the head hit his helmet, and when it jarred him it wasn’t violent. Had he not had any prior concussions, my guess is that he would have been fine. It rattled his head, which is enough for a player with that kind of concussion history. So that takes Crosby out for this series, although if it goes to a Game 7 then I can see him getting back.
Conor Sheary is also out with a concussion. My guess is that, due to the ‘magic’ of playoff hockey, he’s back for Game 6 and only misses two. There’s Dr. Dobber’s best guess.
The main concern is the long-term impact. How many more concussions will Crosby put up with? He loves hockey, but he’s also a sensible person. He’s not going to keep playing if he takes another five concussions. So what’s the magic number – three more? Two? ONE? If the next one is serious enough it’s certainly possible. That’s food for thought.
*
As for Sheary, he’s a small player as it is. Yes, this one was a fluke, but some players get hit by ‘fluke’ more than others – and with smaller players it’s more of a concern. I really want to see Sid and the Kids play next year at least 77 games each. But I fear Sheary only plays 60 to 65 and Crosby just 70.
*
The Maple Leafs just made a strange move. The Shana-plan had been doing incredibly well, but committing yourself for seven years at $4.5 million per season on a defenseman who was unexpectedly decent is just begging to be regretted in two years. Nikita Zaitsev was average. We expected a depth defender with upside who needed time to adjust and what we got was an NHL-ready defenseman worthy of most good team’s No.4 slot. But it was just one year! Here is what I would do. I would offer him three years at $3.5 million per season, or one year at $4.5 million. I would not want my hands tied when the Big 3 kids come up for negotiation. I don’t care if I lose him (to the KHL, or otherwise) – that’s the price. Sign it or go. Management doesn’t take that stance enough in pro sports and that’s why we have lockouts.
Here are defensemen I would rather have:
Jacob Trouba (who signed for less – two years, $3 million per)
Matt Dumba (two years, $2.55 per)
Torey Krug, who makes more per season ($5.25) but only locked in for four seasons – and frankly I’d rather that than Zaitsev’s seven years.
I mean…Zaitsev’s contract is almost the same as Morgan Rielly’s! Really?
*
The Rangers jumped to a 4-0 lead and this time they hung on. But you have to admit (unless you’re a Rangers fan) – you smiled a little when J-G Pageau scored late in the second because you thought “here we go again!” But that was all the Sens managed. Pageau, by the way, has scored the last four Ottawa goals.
With two points last night, Mats Zuccarello has five in his last four games. He had just one point in five games to start the postseason so he’s turning it on just in time.
I was just reviewing Henrik Lundqvist’s game logs and realized that he’s only had one weak game: Saturday’s game. And really, that was one weak period. He had a couple of easy ones in the first round where he wasn’t really challenged, but overall the Lundqvist of old – King Henrik – has made a return appearance. Nine games into the postseason and his SV% is 0.935. All the doubts that I had about the Rangers in March and early April revolved entirely around my belief that he had lost a step. He has lost a step, but like many greats before him he’s added three steps when it matters most.
*
Zack Smith left the game with an upper-body injury courtesy of this hit from JT Miller:
I looked at the hit a hundred times and can’t pinpoint what exactly was hurt there. No update was given after the game.
Also injured was Bobby Ryan, this one was because of this Erik Karlsson shot here:
The puck hit him just above his left knee – I’m thinking a contusion of some severity.
*
Joonas Korpisalo, who is a restricted free agent this summer, had his KHL rights traded. When things like this happen it means something. The KHL team feels they have a chance to convince him to cross the pond. Either they heard something through his agent, or they’re speculating. Columbus needs to sign him quickly if he’s eligible for the expansion draft. And they need to sign one of he or Anton Forsberg or they won’t have a goalie exposed for expansion, which is not allowed.
*
This year’s Russian big free agent – Vadim Shipachyov. He’s apparently fielding some big NHL offers (that are of the non-Montreal variety). He’s been a top scorer in that league for several years now, but he took it to another level in 2016-17 with 76 points in 50 games playing with Ilya Kovalchuk and Nikita Gusev (Tampa). He led the league with 50 assists. He’s 30 years old, so don’t go treating him like the next Panarin. He may just be a Dopita or a Cervenka. But definitely worth drafting in deep keepers.
*
Lundqvist and Rinne – the two aging goaltenders with declining skill are bringing forth shades of their younger selves. Pekka Rinne sat at a 0.914 SV% in early March and ended up 0.918 with a strong final month. And now in the playoffs he’s been just as phenomenal as Lundqvist. This doesn’t sell me on future regular seasons, but it does convince me that I need to take veteran goaltenders with long track records a lot more seriously come playoff time.
Ryan Ellis now has points in seven consecutive games. Have you seen his beard? Between his breakout and Brent Burns, maybe we’ll see more defensemen grow them?
All that talent on the blue line for Nashville – Ellis, Subban, Josi…and yet none of them led the Preds in PP ice time. No, that was Mattias Ekholm, who saw 3:56 with the man advantage. This is a player who couldn’t buy much more than a sniff of PP time over the years and now he’s suddenly Johnny Quarterback.
Interesting to note that Jori Lehtera played just seven minutes last night, a low for the season by far. And he assisted on the only goal for the Blues. He has four points in six playoff games.
*
The 2017-18 products are now up in the shop for pre-sale! The Fantasy Prospects Report is out on June 1 and the Fantasy Hockey Guide (my 12th) is out August 1. Some notes on this:
1. Tax is now charged based on your location. Meaning for the first time, US/International/Alberta readers save $$. Previously they had to pay 13% HST. Now every province pays their own tax rate, and International readers pay nothing for tax. First time ever – I have a new accountant who sees things differently. Great news for at least half of you!
2. USD$ currency is now at $1.37 Canadian. I can't help this, but what I'm able to do is – for pre-sale only – offer a 5% coupon for the Keeper League Fantasy Pack. Coupon Code for the KLFP is: win1
This is only for the month of May (i.e. only for pre-orders). But I feel this will take a bit of the sting out of the nasty exchange rate. I try to keep my pricing based on a $1.20 – $1.25 exchange rate and it's been higher than that for a couple of years now and I have no idea how this will bounce in the coming months.
3. If you've never tried out the Fantasy Hockey Geek Draft Kit, now is a great time to order it – just $5 via our DraftKings deal – basically if you buy my Guide (or one of the packs) and deposit $5 into DraftKings, they'll buy your Geek Draft Kit ($15.99 value)
Details for all of these things are in the shop here
11 Comments
Leave A Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
I can’t speak for the rest of them, but THIS NYR fan is having a great time watching JGP play hockey. Have always had a soft spot for the smaller players in the NHL. It started with Mark Pavelich for me. Mike Rogers, Ken Linesman, Theo Fluery, Denis Maruk, Verbeek and many others have made watching hockey even more entertaining. It will be interesting to see if the shorter stature goalies can make a run of it. Looking at you Saros !
Me too! But I’m probably a little biased because I own him
I like Zaitsev’s deal a lot. He was a rookie, played top pairing minutes & like all players regardless of age has to develop & learn the NHL game. For Dman that’s 400 games. Being older he may be able to accelerate that development curve maybe not. In another year when Trouba’s contract jumps to 6+ & Dumba’s to at least 5+ lets readdress those contract comparisons.
This contract will look like great value in 2 years, possibly sooner & based on his contributions last year he is worth 4.5 now. 3rd in rookie scoring for Dman made the top 40 overall, 6 points out of the top 20. I perceive this as great value. A top 3 Dman that can skate gets 4 million in a walk & Zaitsev played as TO’s #2 by TI/GP, 9 seconds less than Reilly at #1. Dekeyser 5, Demers 4.5, Coburn 3.7, Maatta 4.083, Spurgeon 5.1875, Petry 5.5, etc.
What do you think is going to happen to the salaries for Dman over the next 7 years? I can assure you a Dman of Zaitsev’s quality will be making well in access of 6 million by the time this contract is up & Zaitsev. Zaitsev will be 33 when it expires.
I think the salaries of Dmen over the next 7 years will go way, way up. Do you know why I think this? Because there are always GM’s like Lou who will always overpay dmen like Zaitsev. You’re describing the root of your problem as your answer, rather than addressing the problem. This is a brutal overpay, and the Leafs are by no means alone in doing it. It is just notable because they hadn’t done anything like this in two years. I liked Rielly and Kadri’s deals.
If Zaitsev pisses off Leaf fans in 2019 or 2020 (almost a guarantee, unless he’s at his absolute peak with almost no mistakes), then this contract will be regretted.
I keep thinking of Kaberle – so beloved at 26-30 and so reviled at 31-33 until he was chased out.
Using that thought process we both agree as usual. That means almost every player in the NHL is overpaid. This whole business model is flawed. The concept of comparisons isn’t suitable. No 2 teams scenario’s are identical nor 2 players exactly the same. They have similarities but no way to really compare them. I force players to accept the terms for as long as I old the power. 2 or 3 year bridge deal, then upon expiry look at the long term contract if it’s a player you want to lock up. Like Yzerman has done with Kucherov & others. Yes the player can play the arbitration card coming out of their bridge deal. See Trouba. That gives you 2 years to find a suitable trade if you can’t lock the player up. Trouba would be a UFA if he chooses arbitration & takes a 2 year award.
With each CBA we take small steps to solving these issues. The Canadian dollar has put the breaks on run away contracts for most but not all, Kopitar!; The Canadian dollar is in free fall, most major currency traders & Banks have the Can $ at 67 cents by the end of 2018! but few GM’s use sanity when handing out contracts, they are few & far between. Poille being 1 of the few. In the next CBA we just need the players share of revenue dropped from 50% to 45; so all teams have the potential to be profitable with out having to make the playoffs, terms set on 2nd contracts coming out of ELC’s, ideally 2 but no more than 3 years, binding contracts being eliminated for any player at age 28. Contract can be terminated on their 28th birthday or beyond if teams so desire.
The trade off to the NHLPA for driving these concessions down their throats. Free agency 1 year after your 2nd contract expires. ELC 3 years, 2nd bridge contract 2 or possibly 3 years, +1 then a UFA. Sign & play as an 18 year old your a UFA at potentially 24 or 25. An 8 year max deal deal potentially carries you to 32 or 33 but if your washed up can be sent packing at 28. Revenue sharing is significantly modified. I suggest the NFL’s model of gate sharing & that the have teams give far more monies to the have nots.
These teams took all this expansion revenue & wouldn’t be making all this money if not for expansion. Far greater revenue sharing is needed. The top 4 teams in the NHL make more money than the other 26 combined & that’s just in Hockey related revenue as agreed to by the NHL & NHLPA. It doesn’t account for the spin off revenue many garner because of their NHL teams. Which for a team like NYR dwarfs their hockey related revenue. The own & broadcast themselves in the largest market in NA.
We agree to disagree about Zaitsev. I love this deal for Toronto. It’s reasonable today & will seem like great value for the vast majority of the term. Finding a Dman with a pulse is a serious challenge. Most teams in the NHL would be happy to have Zaitsev especially at 4.5 for 7 years. In 5 years when your paying the soft #3 Dman of the world 6+ we will look back at this saying boy was Toronto smart to lock Zaitsev up & his NTC which kicks in in year 3 only allows for a 10 team no trade list that leaves 20 teams he can be moved to if required.
The rules for goalies differ from forwards & Dman. They don’t need to be signed, they just need to be RFA’s & qualified. Qualifying season hasn’t started yet.
“iii) One goaltender who is under contract in 2017-18 or will be a restricted free agent at the expiration of his current contract immediately prior to 2017-18. If the club elects to make a restricted free agent goaltender available in order to meet this requirement, that goaltender must have received his qualifying offer prior to the submission of the club’s protected list.”
Crap – I had a blurb written, then realized my ‘mistake’ (which now I see wasn’t a mistake) and re-wrote that blurb! I should have left it, now I have to re-think what I wrote
Ha-ha!
Ekholm has essentially been a fixture on the #2 PP in Nashville since Jones was traded. Nashville runs 2 set PP units. Josi & Ekholm man the points on 1 in these playoffs, Subban & Ellis on the other. Ekholm got 8 seconds more than Josi last night a line change issue.
By PP TOI/GP in Nas’s 8 playoff games this season Josi 2:11, Subban 2:08, Ellis 1:25 & Ekholm 1:03. Regular season Josi 3:01, Subban 2:36, Ellis 2:11 & Ekholm 1:25. 2015-16. playoffs PP TOI/GP Josi 3:18, Weber 3:18, Ellis 2:23 & Ekholm 2:19. Regular season, Jones played 40 games before being traded effecting Ekholm’s PP TOI/GP he saw virtually none before this trade. Josi 3:03, Weber 3:03 & Ekholm 1:08.
Ekholm posted 8 goals & 35 points in 2015-16. A taste of things to come? Those #’s regressed to 3 & 23 this season. Odd as both his icetime & PP time increased as did his shots but if we dig deeper his ES & PK minutes jumped more than off setting that increase, as did his defensive responsibility, he’s Subban’s safety net, he stays home 5 on 5 so Subban can rush the puck. With 303 regular season games played Ekholm is still 97 games from my full break out point for Dman.
Like you were discussing with Risto; Risto isn’t coming off Buffalo’s PP anytime soon, I assume about 10 years, the other day & Pietro with Shatty, Ekholm’s solid defensive play hinders his offensive contributions. I think a slightly better comparison here may be Hamonic. Who when deployed in a regular PP role can run a PP & put up good points but as he’s so valuable 5 on 5 & the PK not a role he gets used in often. Larsson would be another. He has also as shown when given PP time can run a PP & put up points but these guys are pigeon holed into defensive roles as someone has to. We may not yet be wrong on Larsson. He’s only played 353 NHL regular season games. The best is yet to come for Ekholm & Larsson. Both are just entering their prime & will be fully developed by the end of next season.
Crosby is unique in that he is a very polarizing player to passionate fans. You either love him or you hate him. Because of this, “the hit” will be a dispute that will never be argued conclusively. That said, I’m quite certain that all fans wish him well for a quick and complete recovery. NOTE: The juvenile side of me would prefer that his recovery occurs after the Pens are eliminated by the Caps.
How many more concussions can Crosby suffer before he calls it quit? This TSN article gives quite a scary answer: “If Crosby was an amateur, he’d be advised to quit right now”.
http://www.tsn.ca/neurosurgeon-says-if-crosby-were-an-amateur-he-d-be-advised-to-quit-hockey-1.741674