Analytics Advantage: Opportunity Knocks, Week 8: Evaluating This Season, and Buying on Nazar, Malinski, Yamamoto, Rinzel, and More

Stas Pupkov

2026-11-20

Nearly every team has played 20 games – only the Seattle Kraken fall short with 19 matchups – so it’s time to grade what I told you in October. Some of it held and a lot of it didn’t, and I’ll say which. Then the wire, because four stars got hurt this week and their minutes went somewhere.

Do this first

•  Add first: Frank Nazar in Chicago, at 85 percent of the power-play time over the last three games, on 24 percent of ESPN rosters.

•  Three-game add: Sam Malinski in Colorado. Malinski has 43 percent of the power-play time since Cale Makar went out, and Colorado plays three times before Makar’s expected return.

•  Add if they’re on your wire: Pavel Zacha, Gabriel Vilardi and Jimmy Snuggerud from the top of this week’s card.

•  Deep leagues: Sam Rinzel in Chicago, Kailer Yamamoto in Utah and Connor Brown in New Jersey.

•  Watch: Tyler Bertuzzi for one more game, and Jack Roslovic‘s power-play time in Toronto.

•  Four games: Anaheim, Calgary, Minnesota, New Jersey, the Islanders, Ottawa, San Jose, Seattle, Utah and Winnipeg. Two games: Buffalo and Carolina.

The report card

I keep a file of every forecast this column and my preseason pieces made, with the rule for grading each one written down before the games. Here’s what it says at 20 games.

Team points. In October I printed a points forecast for all 32 teams, next to the betting line. It’s a tie so far. On raw points pace my forecasts miss by 16.6 points on average and the line misses by 17.1, and mine is closer on 16 of the 31 teams with 20 games played. Pace is noisy this early, because a hot month has Minnesota on a 133-point pace over 84 games. So, I also checked against the model’s current full-season projection for each team. That projection uses last season’s results the same way my October forecast did, so the two aren’t independent. There it’s 7.3 against 8.4. Neither gap is big enough to call.

On the teams where we disagreed, it went both ways. I was closer on Florida, Toronto and Ottawa. I had Florida at 92 against a line of 108, and the current projection is 93. The line was closer on Minnesota, Edmonton and Buffalo. Minnesota was my worst miss, a 96-point forecast for a team now projected at 116.

Goalie starts. This is the report-card item with the most misses, and it matters for your roster. I gave each starter a range of starts for the full season. Of the 29 I can check, 13 are on a pace outside that range, and 11 of the 13 are below it. A 22-game pace is noisy, so that isn’t a final grade. But 11 of 13 on the low side says I had starters too high. Jesper Wallstedt went the other way, with 21 starts in Minnesota’s 24 games against a forecast of 47 for the year. Spencer Knight has 18 of Chicago’s 22. On the low side, Scott Wedgewood has 7 of Colorado’s 23, Brandon Bussi has 8 of Carolina’s 22 and Jakub Dobes has 9 of Montreal’s 23.

Power-play jobs. In September I named eight players whose draft price depended on a power-play role. Seven of them needed a first-unit job, and the rule for those was top five on the team in power-play time. Mark Stone is fourth in Vegas and Mika Zibanejad is second on the Rangers, so those two hold. Shea Theodore is sixth, Alex Tuch is seventh and Victor Hedman is 11th, at 9 percent of Tampa’s power-play time, so those three don’t. Ryan Nugent-Hopkins has played 12 of Edmonton’s 24 games and Brock Faber has played three, so I can’t grade either yet. The eighth call was different. I said Noah Dobson‘s price would hold on a second unit, and that’s the job he has, on Montreal’s second unit in 20 of 22 games. So the role is as called, and whether the price holds gets graded on points in April.

Rookie minutes. Roman Kantserov was the big miss. I had him at 11.7 minutes a night and he’s played 18.8 through 20 games in Chicago. Gavin McKenna has played 14.1 against a forecast of 15.6. In week two I wrote that Tristan Luneau was holding top-pair minutes in Anaheim. Luneau is at 20.2 minutes a night, about five fewer than he was playing then.

Week-two calls. Jack Quinn kept the job. Quinn is at 18.9 minutes a night this season with 72 percent of Buffalo’s power-play time. Luca Cagnoni has played 9 of San Jose’s 24 games and none since Oct. 27. My rule was half of the team’s power-play time through 20 games, so that’s a miss.

Who gains when a star is out. In week three I forecast more ice time for Sam Bennett and Anton Lundell with Aleksander Barkov and Brad Marchand hurt. It went the other way. Bennett played 16.7 minutes a night over the next 10 games against a forecast of 20.4, and Lundell played 17.1 against 19.1. Across all six players in that forecast I missed by 1.3 minutes on average, and four of the six landed inside my range. But just assuming nothing changes missed by 1.6, and the forecast was closer on only three of the six. So it didn’t beat doing nothing. For Colorado and Chicago below, I’m using the games already played and no forecast.

📢 advertisement:

Team offence. I had six things to watch from my October team piece. Five of them only run through Nov. 6, so they’re provisional. Three are going the way I flagged. Dallas’s five-on-five shot attempt rate is 52.1 per 60 against 49.4 last season, Pittsburgh is still getting to the inside at 18.6 attempts per 60, and Buffalo’s finishing came back to earth. Carolina’s finishing is too close to call. Two missed. Edmonton’s shot attempt rate kept falling, to 49.8 per 60 from 56.1. And I flagged Anaheim’s power play for a drop. The Ducks have 27 power-play goals in 23 games through Thursday, tied with Edmonton and Utah for the league lead, after 49 all of last season.

Still to grade from the file: the minutes calls for five veterans who changed teams, which run to April, and a handful of role calls from weeks one to three.

Jobs the injuries opened

Colorado lost Nathan MacKinnon for a month and Makar for two weeks. Malinski has played more than 22 minutes in each of the three games since and took nine shots. He’s on 18 percent of rosters. But it’s a short job, because Makar is expected back around Nov. 29 and Colorado plays only Nov. 25, 27 and 28 before then. Malinski’s share also dropped in the last game, when he got 82 of Colorado’s 279 power-play seconds. History gives a spot like his 57 percent, but that history doesn’t know Makar is coming back.

Up front in Colorado, the power-play time went to Brock Nelson, who has four points in those three games and is on 80 percent of rosters already.

Chicago’s Connor Bedard left Tuesday’s game and there’s no timeline yet. Nazar had this job before that, though. Nazar has 85 percent of the power-play time over the last three games, about the same as a week ago, and Bedard played in two of those three. So the job doesn’t depend on the injury, which is why he’s the first add. Nazar has four goals in the three games since last week’s column and 11 on the year. He’s on 24 percent of rosters, up from 11 a week ago. In the past, 41 percent of forwards in a spot like his went on to be 12-team starters.

Rinzel got his job the same week. He’s been on Chicago’s first unit for four straight games, and that run began before Bedard got hurt. He has nine points in the last five. Rinzel is on 8 percent of rosters. Only 28 percent of past defencemen in a spot like his became 12-team starters, and that’s from 29 cases, so it’s a deep-league add.

In Utah, Nick Schmaltz is on injured reserve and week to week, and Dylan Guenther was expected to miss two to four weeks as of last week. Yamamoto took a first-unit spot the game after Schmaltz went down. Yamamoto has 77 percent of the power-play time over the last three and 12 points in 14 games. He’s on 16 percent of rosters, and Utah plays four times. The history rate for his spot is 19 percent, and neither injury has a return date, so I can’t tell you how long it lasts.

None of those four is on this week’s card, for two different reasons. Nazar fits the card’s deep-league group, but that group shows three players, ranked by projected points per game, and he’s fourth. Malinski, Rinzel and Yamamoto hold spots the card has no group for.

Who to add this week

Figure 1: who to add this week, with the history odds for each player’s spot

The card has three groups, and they aren’t equal. The top group is forwards who were 12-team starters last season and hold half or more of a power play now. Among players like that who were still available, 67 percent stayed starters. The middle group is at 57 percent. In the deep-league group at the bottom, 41 percent became starters.

Zacha is back in the top group, with 80 percent of Boston’s power-play time over the last three games and 17 points in 21. He’s on just under half of rosters. Vilardi has 73 percent of Winnipeg’s power-play time and four games next week. Snuggerud is at 58 percent, because St. Louis is splitting its power-play time close to evenly now.

Two names in that group are cold. Viktor Arvidsson has no points in the last five games, and Charlie Coyle has one. Both are still shooting, with 14 and 18 shots in those five, and both hold the job. Arvidsson is at 76 percent of Detroit’s power-play time and Coyle at 82 percent of Columbus’s. Last week’s test said shots are the thing to trust when the points go quiet, so I’d keep both.

Matthew Knies and Matty Beniers are on the card, and last week I told you to pass on both. Knies has four points in three games since. Beniers has three in two, with seven shots on Thursday. The shots test is a group rate and one week is a small sample, so I’m not changing it. The card’s history has Knies in the 67 percent group, though, and I was wrong on the week.

For deep leagues, Brown is on 4 percent of rosters. Brown has 61 percent of New Jersey’s power-play time over the last three games and 10 points in 14 games. The Devils play four. Zach Benson is in that group too, but Buffalo plays twice next week.

Last week’s calls

The adds mostly scored. Nazar had four goals. Johnson and Vilardi each had four points in three games, Snuggerud had three in three, and Olofsson scored three times in four. Benson had two points in three games.

📢 advertisement:

Four calls went against me. I said to drop Bertuzzi in 12-team leagues, and Bertuzzi has three goals and four points in three games since. Kyle Palmieri was the other drop, and he has three points in three. Knies and Beniers were the two passes, and both scored.

On Bertuzzi, I’d wait for a second game. He had no power-play time on Nov. 12 or Nov. 14. Then he got 111 of Chicago’s 316 power-play seconds on Tuesday and 284 of 379 on Thursday, the first game without Bedard. The moves card has him at 47 percent over his last three games, which includes one of the games with none. Bertuzzi is on 32 percent of rosters.

Philip Broberg was last week’s defence add and has one point in three games. He still has the job in St. Louis at 62 percent of the power-play time. Charle-Edouard D’Astous was the fallback, and he lost the job. D’Astous got 29 of Tampa’s 286 power-play seconds in the two games since Brayden Point came back.

Quinton Byfield didn’t score in three games. Byfield is still at 66 percent of the Kings’ power-play time with seven shots, so I’d keep him one more week.

Who just moved on the power play

Figure 2: who moved onto or off the first unit, with how often moves like it held

Vasily Podkolzin is on Edmonton’s first unit at 66 percent over the last three games and has 12 goals. He’s on 86 percent of rosters. Vincent Trocheck is at 74 percent in Utah with the two injuries there. Neal Pionk is down to 28 percent in Winnipeg.

Not on the card

I left Tampa and Dallas off the card, because each got a star back this week and a three-game window mixes two lineups. Point is back on Tampa’s first unit, with 239 of 286 power-play seconds in two games since returning. In Dallas, Miro Heiskanen was due back Tuesday and played. Thomas Harley has 176 of Dallas’s 480 power-play seconds in the two games since, so Harley’s first-unit run is over.

Toronto, winless in eight, changed its power play on Thursday. McKenna moved to the top group and got 289 of Toronto’s 391 power-play seconds. Roslovic got 118. Roslovic has 22 points in 23 games, so don’t drop him yet. Toronto has been splitting its time close to evenly, and Roslovic is at 42 percent over the last three. That number is what I’d check next week.

Injuries to watch

Barkov and Marchand are both nearing a return for Florida and see the doctors on Friday. Florida’s next game is Saturday against Buffalo, so check who dressed before you set a lineup.

Montreal lost Chris Kreider for six to eight weeks, and Josh Anderson and Mike Matheson are out as well. Zack Bolduc had moved up to 58 percent of the power-play time, and then he sat out Thursday with no timeline. Wait on that one.

Tampa put Brandon Hagel and Conor Geekie on injured reserve.

This week

•  Add: Nazar, and Malinski for three games.

•  Add if they’re on your wire: Zacha, Vilardi and Snuggerud.

•  Deep leagues: Rinzel, plus Yamamoto and Brown with four games each.

•  Keep: Arvidsson, Coyle and Byfield through the cold stretch.

•  Watch: Bertuzzi for one more game, and Roslovic’s power-play time.

Extra resources from Daily Faceoff, NHL.com, TSN and ESPN. Projections, history odds and the report card are my own. Games through Nov. 19, ESPN ownership as of Nov. 20. Five of the six team-offence reads run through Nov. 6.

Leave A Comment

Starting Goalies

No games found.

Top Skater Views

  Players Team
LOGAN MAILLOUX STL
RYAN LEONARD WSH
SAM RINZEL CHI
FRANK NAZAR CHI
CHARLE-EDOUARD D'ASTOUS T.B

Top Goalie Profile Views

  Players Team
LOGAN THOMPSON WSH
SEBASTIAN COSSA UTA
JOEL HOFER STL
JACOB FOWLER MTL
DANIIL TARASOV DET

LINE COMBOS

  Frequency NYR Players
24.0 MIKA ZIBANEJAD GABE PERREAULT ALEXIS LAFRENIERE
22.6 J.T. MILLER TYE KARTYE WILL CUYLLE
15.0 EELI TOLVANEN NOAH LABA OLIVER BJORKSTRAND

DobberHockey Podcasts

Fantasy Hockey Life: Minnesota and Vancouver Dynasty Stock Watch

This week, Victor and Jesse talk Minnesota Wild and Vancouver Canucks prospects. Included: Adam Benák, Ryder Ritchie, Riley Heidt, Charlie Stramel, Aron Kiviharju, David Špaček, Zeev Buium, Braeden Cootes, Liam Öhgren, Jonathan Lekkerimäki, Tom Willander, Elias Pettersson (D). Have a listen! Our show is part of the Dobber Podcast Network and sponsored by Fantrax.com. Email […]

FIND US ON FACEBOOK