Victor Hedman vs. John Carlson

Rick Roos

2013-08-28

VictorHedman

 

Who is the better own in fantasy hockey – Hedman or Carlson?

 

 

 

This week's match features two young defensemen (Victor Hedman and John Carlson) who've been on the fantasy radar for their entire careers, but so far haven't been able to make the leap into the elite defenseman category. The question is which one is more worthwhile to own. Let's find out by looking at the key side-by-side comparisons.

Hits

Blocked Shots

PIMs

Shots

2012-13

+1 (Hedman)

+11 (Carlson)

56 (Hedman)

59 (Carlson)

84 (Hedman)

123 (Carlson)

31 (Hedman)

18 (Carlson)

76 (Hedman)

97 (Carlson)

2011-12

-9 (Hedman)

-15 (Carlson)

96 (Hedman)

83 (Carlson)

127 (Hedman)

153 (Carlson)

65 (Hedman)

22 (Carlson)

82 (Hedman)

152 (Carlson)

2010-11

+3 (Hedman)

+21 (Carlson)

54 (Hedman)

70 (Carlson)

85 (Hedman)

160 (Carlson)

70 (Hedman)

44 (Carlson)

101 (Hedman)

144 (Carlson)

 

What's interesting is that three of these categories have clear winners, with Hedman having many more PIMs than Carlson each season (but neither player is penalized very much) and Carlson having many more Blocked Shots (50% more one season; nearly double in another) and more Shots (nearly double in one season) than Hedman. And it's also worth noting that Carlson's stats in these two secondary categories were huge (3rd in the NHL in Blocked Shots in 2012-13; 11th among defensemen in Shots). Plus/minus was back and forth, with Carlson oddly being either better than +10 or worse than -10, and Hits was close enough that we should expect it to remain basically a wash. Overall, Carlson holds an edge in more categories, and it's a valuable edge since he's among the elite in those categories.

 

Value vs. Cost

Up to this point we've seen that Hedman and Carlson have pretty comparable overall value, so one important thing to do as part of this analysis is compare each player's value in relation to the cost it would take to get him, whether by trade or in a draft. And the reality is that Carlson will likely cost you more to obtain than Hedman. This is mainly because Carlson plays for Washington, and many folks think that based on what Mike Green has done Carlson might do the same (or close to it). Plus, Carlson is essentially heading into his "magical fourth year", and that might entice some poolies. Also, despite Hedman's points pace actually trending upward, he still hasn't scored more than 26 points in a season, and people will focus on that, even more so because it seems quite disappointing for a former #2 overall pick. When it comes to value versus cost, I give an edge to Hedman.

 

So Who Wins?

Doing this Cage Match reminded me why I feel sympathy for people who own guys like John Carlson in fantasy leagues. When you look at his ice time in particular, it's clear that he has so much value to his team as a shutdown defenseman that it's actually holding back his offense. But can you blame the Capitals? They already have plenty of offensive production, including Mike Green from the blueline (and perhaps Dmitri Orlov if he ever develops), so they're glad to use Carlson in a role where he's counted upon primarily to prevent the opposition's goals rather than helping his own team score.

And while it's not like Hedman is being groomed by Tampa Bay to be the next Erik Karlsson, it does appear that the team is becoming more comfortable giving him additional opportunities to contribute on the score sheet. And Hedman has responded by slowly but steadily increasing his point scoring pace in each of the last three seasons.

In the end, I think the edge goes to Hedman, mainly based on value versus cost, upward trending in points scoring, and concerns about the Mike Green effect on Carlson. But that edge is not too large, which means it could just as easily tilt toward Carlson if, for example, your league emphasizes secondary categories in the areas (Shots, Blocked Shots) where Carlson not only is clearly better than Hedman but is one of the best among all NHL defensemen.

 

 

 

 

 

Recent Cage Matches:

 

 

Brad Marchand vs. T.J. Oshie 
Holding Court – Final Verdict 
Bryan Bickell vs. Troy Brouwer 
PA Parenteau vs. Jason Pominville 

Leave A Comment

UPCOMING GAMES

Oct 07 - 17:10 FLA vs CHI
Oct 07 - 20:10 NYR vs PIT
Oct 07 - 22:10 L.A vs COL

Starting Goalies

Top Skater Views

  Players Team
YEGOR CHINAKHOV CBJ
DAKOTA JOSHUA TOR
JOE VELENO MTL
MASON MCTAVISH ANA
JACK ROSLOVIC

Top Goalie Profile Views

  Players Team
LUKAS DOSTAL ANA
IVAN FEDOTOV PHI
JET GREAVES CBJ
SPENCER KNIGHT CHI
THATCHER DEMKO VAN

LINE COMBOS

  Frequency ARI Players
25.8 NICK SCHMALTZ ALEXANDER KERFOOT CLAYTON KELLER
17.5 DYLAN GUENTHER LAWSON CROUSE LOGAN COOLEY
17.2 AKU RATY JACK MCBAIN MATIAS MACCELLI

DobberHockey Podcasts

Fantasy Hockey Life: Washington Capitals Preview with Dan Holmi of Locked on Caps

Dan Holmi is here to report on the Washington Capitals. Jesse and Victor interview Dan about returning pros Alex Ovechkin, Dylan Strome, Aliaksei Protas, Pierre-Luc Dubois, Tom Wilson, Connor McMichael, Ryan Leonard, John Carlson, Jakob Chychrun, Rasmus Sandin, Logan Thompson, and Charlie Lindgren. In Cat’s Instincts, Cat Silverman of InGoal mag breaks down Garin Bjorklund.  […]

Fantasy Hockey Life: Stefan Rosner on the New York Islanders

Stefan Rosner is here to report on the New York Islanders. Jesse and Victor interview Stefan Rosner about returning pros Bo Horvat, Anders Lee, Mathew Barzal, Simon Holmstrom, JG Pageau, Maxim Tsyplakov, Calum Ritchie, Noah Dobson, Ryan Pulock, Alexander Romanov, Scott Perunovich, and Ilya Sorokin. In Cat’s Instincts, Cat Silverman of InGoal mag breaks down […]

FIND US ON FACEBOOK