Top 50 One-Year (Roto) Goalie Rankings
Michael Amato
2021-09-08
With fantasy hockey drafts quickly approaching, developing a plan on where to draft your goalies can give you a big advantage over your competition. You can target a couple of top tier goalies early on to really solidify that spot on your roster, but that's not necessarily always the best choice. Depending on your league categories, sometimes it's better to build other positions first and target goaltenders in the later rounds. There's often better value to be had with some goalies that fall down the board in your drafts.
DobberHockey’s 16th annual Fantasy Hockey Guide is out now, fully updated and ready for download. Pick it up here!
Let's take a look at the top 50 goalies for the 2021-22 season in non-keeper leagues.
- Andrei Vasilevskiy – Tampa Bay Lightning
The best goalie on the best team. There's no debate about this one.
2. Connor Hellebuyck – Winnipeg Jets
I think you could argue the order of 2-4 all day, but Hellebuyck gets my vote because he'll play the most and Winnipeg's defense should be much improved.
3. Darcy Kuemper – Colorado Avalanche
Arguably the player who benefited the most this offseason by changing teams.
4. Robin Lehner – Vegas Golden Knights
The undisputed No. 1 in Vegas now.
5. Igor Shesterkin – New York Rangers
Great start to his NHL career and no one to challenge him for starts. Shesterkin led the league in high-danger save percentage last year.
6. Semyon Varlamov – New York Islanders
You could argue he should be ahead of Shesterkin, but splitting time with Sorokin drops him slightly.
7. Marc-Andre Fleury – Chicago Blackhawks
One of the only goalies at his age that can handle a heavy workload and Chicago got better this offseason.
8. Cam Talbot – Minnesota Wild
Talbot was tremendous last season and even better in the playoffs.
9. Juuse Saros – Nashville Predators
Saros proved he could play very well with heavy usage in 2021.
10. Ilya Sorokin – New York Islanders
I think he'll have to closer to a 50/50 split with Varlamov in 2021-22.
11. Tristan Jarry – Pittsburgh Penguins
Don't let his playoff struggles deter you. Jarry was very good in the regular season last year and should be again behind a great Pittsburgh squad.
12. Thatcher Demko – Vancouver Canucks
The Canucks should be much better and Demko may play 55-60 games.
13. Frederik Andersen – Carolina Hurricanes
If he can stay healthy, Andersen will be a steal.
14. Ilya Samsonov – Washington Capitals
If playing for a big money contract doesn't bring the best out of Samsonov, nothing will.
15. Linus Ullmark – Boston Bruins
Numbers were great on a bad Buffalo team and should be even better in Boston.
16. Sergei Bobrovsky – Florida Panthers
Bobrovsky has had his struggles in Florida, but the Panthers have quickly developed into an elite team and he's probably going to get close to 50 starts.
17. Jack Campbell – Toronto Maple Leafs
Campbell would be higher but I don't think he plays more than 40-45 games.
18. Jacob Markstrom – Calgary Flames
Markstrom's numbers start to slip when he's overworked and with Dan Vladar the likely backup, I think it's going to be tough for him to avoid burning out.
19. Philipp Grubauer – Seattle Kraken
I want to rank him higher but I just don't see the Kraken being very good. Grubauer is going to find out very quickly that he isn't in Colorado anymore.
20. Petr Mrazek – Toronto Maple Leafs
Mrazek will probably get close to a 50/50 split with Campbell and Toronto has proven to be a quality regular season team.
21. Spencer Knight – Florida Panthers
If Bobrovsky falters, Knight could be next year's Nedeljkovic.
22. Carey Price – Montreal Canadiens
If Price isn't overused, his save percentage and GAA should improve.
23. Carter Hart – Philadelphia Flyers
The addition of Ryan Ellis should help a bit, but there are still question marks with the Flyers defense.
24. Jordan Binnington – St. Louis Blues
Binnington's numbers have been trending downwards since that remarkable Cup run.
25. Vitek Vanecek – Washington Capitals
Proved he was a capable NHL goalie last year and should get plenty of starts on a strong Capitals squad.
26. Mackenzie Blackwood – New Jersey Devils
Blackwood's value probably depends on how big of a step forward New Jersey is going to take in 2021-22 as a team.
27. Jake Allen – Montreal Canadiens
The Canadiens really didn't want to lose Allen this offseason and he proved last year he can handle a decent workload to keep Price fresh.
28. Jeremy Swayman – Boston Bruins
The Bruins don't like to overwork their starter, so expect Swayman to see plenty of action.
29. Pavel Francouz – Colorado Avalanche
Maybe the best spot in the league to be a goalie. If Francouz is healthy he'll be a big asset to your team.
30. Kaapo Kahkonen – Minnesota Wild
Kahkonen was inconsistent last year but he'll probably get more playing time with an 82-game schedule.
31. Alex Nedeljkovic – Detroit Red Wings
He'll probably get more playing time but it's hard not to take a hit going from Carolina to Detroit.
32. Anton Khudobin – Dallas Stars
The crease is very crowded in Dallas and any one of four goalies could have solid value this year for the Stars. Khudobin figures to be the best option out of the gate and Dallas may have the best defense corps in the league.
33. Mike Smith – Edmonton Oilers
It's going to be tough for Smith to duplicate what he did last year over an 82-game schedule at his age.
34. Jonathan Bernier – New Jersey Devils
He's out of Detroit, but how much better are the Devils?
35. Antti Raanta – Carolina Hurricanes
Arguably the most frustrating fantasy goaltender. Just can't stay healthy.
36. Elvis Merzlikins – Columbus Blue Jackets
Merzlikins posted good numbers last year on a bad Columbus squad. Wins will be hard to come by, though, in 2021-22.
37. Joonas Korpisalo – Columbus Blue Jackets
Sadly, John Tortorella and his goalie friendly system is no more.
38. John Gibson – Anaheim Ducks
Nothing worse than a good goalie stuck on a bad team.
39. Cal Petersen – Los Angeles Kings
Is this finally the year he officially dethrones Quick as the official No. 1?
40. Chris Driedger – Seattle Kraken
Unless Seattle is as good as Vegas was out of the gate, it could be a long year for Driedger.
41. Matt Murray – Ottawa Senators
Ottawa finished strong last year, but I don't think that's going to be enough to make Murray worth drafting.
42. Laurent Brossoit – Vegas Golden Knights
There's some sneaky value for Brossoit next season. I don't see Lehner playing more than 50 games, which means Brossoit will get a fair share of starts with a very good team in front of him.
43. Jaroslav Halak – Vancouver Canucks
Halak is going to miss the great structure he played behind in Boston.
44. Casey DeSmith – Pittsburgh Penguins
DeSmith will have some value off the waiver wire for spot starts, but nothing more.
45. Alexandar Georgiev – New York Rangers
Georgiev hasn't been able to challenge Shesterkin at all for starts.
46. Jake Oettinger – Dallas Stars
Oettinger could be good to stash on your roster if you have the space. Something tells me he may be getting significant playing time later in the season.
47. Kevin Lankinen – Chicago Blackhawks
I think Chicago is going to use Fleury a ton, which is bad news for Lankinen.
48. Thomas Greiss – Detroit Red Wings
It will be hard to squeeze much value out of Greiss in Detroit and with Nedeljkovic now on the scene.
49. Martin Jones – Philadelphia Flyers
Jones is in a better spot now than San Jose, but he'll have to build up some trust first.
50. Tuukka Rask – Boston Bruins
He won't help you for at least the first half of the season, but Rask might be worth stashing on IR if you have space.
For fantasy hockey tips and advice follow me on Twitter at @amato_mike
For starting goalie announcements, follow @GoaliePost
Sign up at www.goaliepost.com for free email notifications about starting goalie announcements and to check the goalie grid for the day's starters. Don't forget to Bookmark!